They're more of a 4.5/5 because they're not my absolute favorite sweaters, but they're definitely decent. Great for the price and in love with the colors. These are perfect for everyday wear in the winter or autumn. It is thinner than I imagined, but I actually like it better because you can layer it without sweating buckets. I understand it is one size, but it's quite cropped on me. Not enough to show my stomach, but if I raise my arms, you'll see it. Still, I believe these are essential to anyone's closet, so I recommend picking one up!